A homeowner in Conshohocken, PA, discovered what appeared to be minor water damage on the second floor of their newly constructed home. The source was a leaking third-floor roof deck, and the builder assured them the problem wasn’t serious. The builder repaired the leak and painted over the visible damage. As far as the homeowner knew, the issue had been resolved.
Three months later, the house began to smell.
Why Roof Decks on New Construction Can Leak
Roof decks are becoming increasingly common on new construction homes, particularly in areas like Conshohocken where builders are maximizing outdoor living space. However, these decks require proper waterproofing, drainage, and flashing around doors, walls, and other penetrations. Poorly installed waterproofing membranes, inadequate flashing, or improper drainage can allow rainwater to enter the structure. Once water gets beneath a roof deck, it can travel through framing cavities and behind finished walls before becoming visible on a lower floor.
That is exactly the type of hidden water movement we encountered on this project.
The Damage Was Much Worse Than Anyone Expected
When MSI was called to investigate the odor, we began opening the areas affected by the original leak. What initially appeared to be damage limited to the second floor turned out to be a much larger problem. Water had entered from the third-floor roof deck and traveled down through the building. As we continued opening affected areas, we traced the damage from the third floor through the second floor and eventually into the first floor. Behind the finished surfaces, we discovered extensive water damage, deteriorated building materials, wood rot, and mold growth.
The visible staining that had been painted over was only a small indication of what had been happening inside the structure.
Why Painting Over Water Damage Doesn’t Fix the Problem
One of the biggest mistakes following a water intrusion is assuming that repairing the leak means the damage has been addressed. Stopping the water source is only the first step. When water enters wall cavities, insulation, subfloors, or structural framing, those materials can remain wet long after the visible surfaces appear dry. If proper moisture testing, drying, and removal of unsalvageable materials aren’t performed, the remaining moisture can contribute to mold growth and deterioration of wood and other building materials. In this case, the builder addressed the leak and covered the visible evidence, but the concealed damage was never properly mitigated.
Three months later, the odor was a warning that something was wrong.
Long-Term Water Damage Can Affect Multiple Floors
Water doesn’t necessarily stay where a stain first appears. It can follow framing, plumbing penetrations, and other pathways through a building. In multistory homes, damage that first appears on one floor may originate above it and extend well below it. That is why a proper water damage assessment must consider the entire path of intrusion, not just the area where staining is visible.
For this Conshohocken home, opening the affected assemblies revealed damage extending across three floors. Without that investigation, much of the deterioration and mold growth would have remained concealed.
Documenting the Damage for a Claim Against the Builder
Another important part of this project was documenting what we found. MSI recorded the extent of the concealed water damage, wood deterioration, and mold as the affected areas were opened. This documentation helped establish that the problem was substantially more extensive than the original cosmetic repairs suggested. The information was used to support an insurance claim against the builder, and the homeowners were ultimately reimbursed. Proper documentation is especially important when water damage involves new construction, previous repairs, or a dispute over responsibility.
Photographs, moisture findings, and records of damaged materials can help explain what happened and why additional work was necessary.
What Homeowners Should Learn From This Conshohocken Project
A new home isn’t immune to water damage, and a builder’s assurance that a leak has been fixed doesn’t necessarily mean the affected building materials are dry. If water has entered a wall, ceiling, or floor assembly, the damage should be properly assessed before the area is patched or painted. This is particularly important when the leak originated from an upper-level roof deck, where water can travel through multiple levels of the structure without being immediately visible. The homeowners in this case were initially told the problem was minor. Three months later, the discovery of mold and wood rot told a very different story.
A repaired leak is not the same as properly mitigated water damage.
If you’re dealing with a roof deck leak, hidden water damage, or suspected mold in Conshohocken, PA, MSI can help identify the extent of the problem and determine the appropriate next steps.
